Niel Tupas

Article 3 Trashed

 

 

Prosecution Panel Chief Niel Tupas, Jr. received his sharpest dressing down yet from Senator-Judge Pontius Enrile when the former tried to restore the trashed “bribery’ factor in Article 3. The said factor constitutes the free tickets and complimentary favors and perks to Chief Justice Renato Corona. These items are not specifically included in the ill-formed and defective Articles of Impeachment, and to include these items would mean that Article 3 would have to be expanded. Anyway, complimentary tickets and perks are not uncommonly provided to the high officials nd high-profile people. All major companies provide these.

The prosecution Panel’s mistake is that they should have presented these items after they have presented the impeachable actions of the respondent, and not present these as the introduction to Article 3.

Ah well, this gives the Senate the opportunity to be dismissed early.

Fireworks

 

Fireworks in the Impeachment Trial of Chief Justice Renato Corona started at the initial dissection of the Articles of Impeachment itself.

Lead Defense Counsel Serafin Cuevas, himself a former Justice, questioned the semantic validity of Article 2 wherein the terms “alleged”, “suspected”, and ” reported”, do not constitute accusations andf will lead to the Prosecution to mere fishing for evidence.

The following video clips show the crux of the disagreement and the intended compromise solution by  Chairman Senator-Judge Juan Ponce Enrile.

Serafin Cuevas

 

Neil Tupas, Jr.

 

Juan Ponce Enrile

 

Cuevas1.mpg

Tupas2.mpg

Enrile1.mpg

 

Niel Tupas, Jr.

 

Niel Tupas, Jr.

Tupas1.mpg